If you were anywhere near an American shopping mall in the 1980s, you don't need me to describe it. You can still smell it: warm chocolate chip cookies drifting out of one storefront, caramel corn from another, soft pretzels, and the orange-vanilla froth of an Orange Julius. The mall wasn't just a place to shop. It was where you went.
Most of those storefronts are gone now. But a surprising number of the brands aren't — they just changed shape. Their stories say a lot about how American businesses rise, stumble, and sometimes come back as something else entirely.
A 20-Year-Old and a Tray of Free Samples
In August 1977, 20-year-old Debbi Fields opened a small cookie shop in Palo Alto, California, called Mrs. Fields' Chocolate Chippery. Almost nobody believed in it — reportedly not even her husband Randy or his friends, though they all loved her cookies.
Opening day was a bust. Nobody came in. So Debbi did what any good performer does with an empty room: she took the show to the audience. She carried trays of warm cookies out onto the street and gave them away, and the samples brought customers back through the door.
Her cookies were different from the crisp, crunchy supermarket kind — soft-baked, made with premium ingredients, and never sold a day old. A year later, the developer of San Francisco's Pier 39 offered her space for a second shop. Then came the malls.
Part of the secret was surprisingly high-tech for a cookie shop. Randy Fields designed a computer system that told each store how many cookies to bake every hour based on past sales — so the cookies were always warm and the waste stayed low. By 1988 there were about 275 stores across the country, and by 1992 Debbi had sold the company to an investment firm for a reported $100 million.
The $250 Cookie Recipe That Never Was
Mrs. Fields even earned a place in American folklore. A chain letter — photocopied and passed around offices long before email made it easy — told the tale of a customer charged $250 for the Mrs. Fields recipe, who got revenge by sharing it with everyone. The company posted signs in its stores denying the story. It was never true; versions of the same legend had been told about other famous recipes for decades. Fake news, it turns out, is older than the internet — it just used to travel by fax machine.
The Food Court Neighbors
Mrs. Fields had plenty of company. Orange Julius actually predates the modern mall by decades — it started in 1926 as Julius Freed's orange juice stand in Los Angeles. Karmelkorn began in Casper, Wyoming, in 1929 and grew to 270 shops in 43 states by 1982. Hot Sam soft pretzels opened their first stand in 1966 at the Livonia Mall near Detroit.
And here's a little Flyover Country pride: the enclosed shopping mall itself is a Minnesota invention. Southdale Center in Edina, which opened in 1956, was the first fully enclosed, climate-controlled shopping mall in the country — a very sensible idea for a place with our winters. The food court wasn't far behind.
How They Faded
Some brands weren't killed so much as absorbed. The Twin Cities–based Dairy Queen bought Karmelkorn in 1986 and Orange Julius in 1987, and began combining all three into Dairy Queen "Treat Centers." By 2018, every standalone Orange Julius had been converted into a Dairy Queen, though the drink itself lives on at select DQ locations. Karmelkorn slowly faded as malls declined and its leases expired, and in May 2019 Dairy Queen dropped support for its last six locations.
Hot Sam met a similar fate by merger. Mrs. Fields' parent company bought it in 1996, then folded it into its Pretzelmaker brand in 2005. The pretzels kept selling. The name didn't.
Mrs. Fields itself had a rougher ride. After the sale, the parent company took on heavy debt and filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2008 under a prepackaged plan that kept stores open — most customers never noticed. It narrowly avoided another bankruptcy in 2011 by turning control over to its creditors, and filed again in 2018, this time as a deliberate restructuring rather than a collapse.
…And How They Came Back
Here's the part I find most interesting. The mall shrank, but the cookie didn't die — it adapted. Mrs. Fields paired many of its storefronts with TCBY frozen yogurt, and franchisees who added both reportedly doubled their profits almost overnight at minimal cost. Today most locations are kiosks, counters, and pop-ups rather than full stores, and a big share of the business is cookie tins and gift boxes shipped nationwide. The company says it still follows Debbi's original 1977 formula and buys the same ingredients.
Even Karmelkorn found a second life, just a much smaller one: a small Nebraska business now makes the popcorn locally and ships it across the country. The History Channel's The Food That Built America has even dramatized the Mrs. Fields founding story — proof that nostalgia has become a product of its own.
Where Are They Now?
- Mrs. Fields: Still baking. Mostly kiosks, TCBY combo counters, and online gift orders; roughly 100+ U.S. locations as of early 2025.
- Orange Julius: No standalone stores since 2018; the drink survives on select Dairy Queen menus.
- Karmelkorn: Gone from malls since 2019; a small Nebraska business sells the popcorn and ships nationwide.
- Hot Sam: Merged into Pretzelmaker in 2005; the name is retired.
The Lesson in the Cookie Tin
The brands that survived didn't do it by staying the same. They did it by figuring out what people actually loved — a warm cookie, a frothy orange drink, the smell of caramel corn — and finding new ways to deliver it when the old storefront stopped working. The businesses that disappeared were often the ones whose identity was the location rather than the product.
Debbi Fields understood that on her very first day. When nobody walked in, she didn't wait for the mall to save her. She walked out with a tray.
Sources & Further Reading
- Mrs. Fields: About the company
- Wikipedia: Mrs. Fields
- Food Republic: What happened to all the Mrs. Fields cookie stores in malls?
- Tasting Table: Do Mrs. Fields cookies still exist?
- Mashed: The untold truth of Mrs. Fields
- Chowhound: 10 vanished mall food court restaurants
- Wikipedia: Karmelkorn
- Wikipedia: Pretzelmaker (and Hot Sam)