Future installments will take on bigger, hotter topics — immigration, voter ID, climate, data centers, artificial intelligence. But let's start with an issue that raises blood pressure only twice a year, when we lose an hour of sleep in March and gain it back in November: daylight saving time.
The next clock change is Sunday, November 1. It may or may not be one of the last.
One Man, Five Positions, Seven Years
Few public figures illustrate this series better than President Trump on the subject of clocks.
What Was Said, and When
- March 2019 “Making Daylight Saving Time permanent is O.K. with me!” (Time)
- Dec. 2024 “The Republican Party will use its best efforts to eliminate Daylight Saving Time” — calling it inconvenient and very costly. (Newsweek)
- March 2025 Calls it “a 50-50 issue,” noting some parents don't want their kids going to school in the dark. (Newsweek)
- April 2025 Urges Congress to “push hard for more Daylight at the end of a day” — back to permanent daylight time. (Fortune)
- May 2026 Promises to “work very hard to see The Sunshine Protection Act signed into Law.” (NBC News)
To be fair, changing your mind isn't a crime, and on this issue the public is genuinely split. But notice the pattern: each position fit the moment and the audience in front of it.
Never a Party-Line Issue
This is not a Republican story or a Democratic one. The 2023 Senate version of the Sunshine Protection Act was cosponsored by Republicans Marco Rubio, James Lankford, Tommy Tuberville, Bill Hagerty, Rick Scott, Cindy Hyde-Smith, and Rand Paul — alongside Democrats Alex Padilla, Ed Markey, Tina Smith of Minnesota, and Ron Wyden.
In March 2022, the full Senate passed it unanimously. New York Democrat Kirsten Gillibrand celebrated, saying permanent daylight time “could help reduce energy costs and seasonal depression.” Then the bill quietly died in the House.
This year, the roles reversed. On July 14, 2026, the House passed it 308–117. Now it's stalled in the Senate, where Arkansas Republican Tom Cotton has long objected that year-round daylight time would leave winter mornings dark, and senators from both parties have raised concerns in committee.
The History Nobody Remembers
Does anyone remember the winter America tried permanent daylight saving time? Neither do I — and that turns out to be the point.
We've tried this before, more than once. The United States first adopted daylight saving time on March 31, 1918, during World War I, to conserve fuel by shifting waking hours into daylight. It was unpopular enough that Congress repealed it in 1919 — overriding President Woodrow Wilson's veto to do it.
Then, in January 1974, amid the Arab oil embargo, President Richard Nixon put the country on year-round daylight time. It lasted about as long as the novelty: support collapsed within weeks as parents watched their children wait for school buses in pitch darkness, and Congress voted to return to standard time less than a year later. Those were the same kids in the dark that President Trump mentioned fifty years later.
It Was Never for the Farmers
One of the most durable myths in American life is that daylight saving time was created to help farmers. It wasn't. Farmers were among its fiercest opponents — in 1919 and again when the first peacetime version arrived in 1966.
The reason is simple: moving the clock doesn't create a single extra minute of sunlight. It only changes what the clock says when the sun comes up. Farmers still worked by sunrise, sunset, morning dew, and the weather — and dairy cows do not adjust their milking schedule because Congress changed the clocks. What the time change did do was throw farmers out of sync with their hired hands, the railroads, the markets, and every city business they depended on.
So Who Wanted the Extra Hour?
- The golf industry told Congress in the 1980s that one extra month of daylight saving was worth $200 million in clubs and greens fees. (NPR)
- The barbecue industry put its value at $100 million in grills and charcoal.
- Candy makers placed candy pumpkins on every senator's seat at a 1985 hearing, according to historian Michael Downing. When the 2005 energy bill extended DST into early November, Halloween finally fell inside the extra hour of evening light.
- Retailers and shopping malls lobbied for more after-work daylight, and more after-work shopping. (CBC)
Every extension was sold as energy policy. But when researchers studied the 2007 extension in California, they found it had “little or no effect on energy consumption.”
Meanwhile, Here in Minnesota
Minnesota lawmakers have been on both sides of the clock, too. Around 2020, bills advanced at the Capitol to put the state on year-round daylight time — but only “upon authorization by federal law.” Eighteen states have passed legislation like that.
Here's where perspective matters. Federal law doesn't allow states to adopt permanent daylight time on their own. So these bills let legislators vote for the popular position, knowing it can't take effect unless Congress acts first. It's a free vote — all of the credit and none of the consequences.
And in 2026, the Minnesota Legislature saw bills pushing the opposite direction: HF 1944 and SF 2403, to drop daylight saving time and adopt permanent standard time, which states are allowed to do. The House sponsor, Rep. Mike Freiberg, admitted he'd actually prefer permanent daylight time, but his larger goal was simply to end the twice-yearly switch.
And the doctors? The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says permanent daylight time would be hard on the body, and supports a competing bill, the Sunshine for Our Kids Act, for permanent standard time.
Seen and Unseen
Seen: politicians promising to “lock the clock” and give you more sunshine.
Unseen: the golf, grill, candy, and retail industries that have shaped the clock for decades — and the kids standing at the bus stop in the dark.
Did the Facts Change, or the Incentives?
Almost everyone agrees on one thing: stop changing the clocks. The fight is over which time to keep — and the positions tend to track who's in the room. Golfers and retailers want the light at the end of the day. Sleep doctors want it in the morning. Parents want it at the bus stop. And politicians are free to flip, because on this issue the vote rarely costs them anything.
The farmers, for their part, couldn't care less. The cows get milked on time either way.
Sources & Further Reading
- Time: Where states stand on changing the clock
- NBC News: House passes Trump-backed bill to make daylight saving time permanent
- Newsweek: Trump calls DST “a 50-50 issue”
- Fortune: Trump urges Congress to push for more daylight
- Sen. Gillibrand: Senate passes the Sunshine Protection Act (2022)
- NPR: The reasoning behind changing daylight saving (Michael Downing interview)
- CBC: How big business benefits from more sunshine
- Minnesota House Session Daily: permanent standard time bill
- WTTW: What impact would permanent daylight saving time have?
- Michael Downing, Spring Forward: The Annual Madness of Daylight Saving Time (2005)