Same homework, new helper. Illustrations by the author, created with Gemini.
If you’re looking for clicks, eyeballs and attention these days, from the internet or the legacy media, the surest way to get them is to fan the flames of fear about artificial intelligence. Post dire warnings about data centers, tech billionaires taking over the world, Chinese and Iranian hackers, fake news, AI movie stars, politicians controlling citizens and rivals fomenting revolution on Facebook, Instagram, X, Quora, Reddit and Medium, and you’ll find an audience eager to believe we’re only a few years away from Terminator 2 and the rise of Skynet.
Education is especially fertile ground. Respected scholars, union leaders and public figures have raised sharp warnings about AI in the classroom:
The Warnings
Noam Chomsky, linguist: in a 2023 interview, called ChatGPT in education “basically high-tech plagiarism” and “a way of avoiding learning.”
The American Federation of Teachers, led by Randi Weingarten: in May 2026, recommended no screens at all for students in second grade and younger, and no AI chatbots for elementary students.
Rebecca Winthrop, Brookings Institution: a January 2026 Brookings report concluded that, for now, AI’s risks to students outweigh its benefits, and warned of a “doom loop of AI dependence.” As Winthrop told NPR, “When kids use generative AI that tells them what the answer is … they are not thinking for themselves.”
Michael Bloomberg: in an October 2025 op-ed, warned that AI is “a technology that could set students back even further than mobile phones have.”
Sen. Bernie Sanders: in a December 2025 CNN interview, worried that kids already struggle to read books and have short attention spans, and that they may come to rely on AI for emotional support.
Hugh Grant, actor: has campaigned in Britain against “screen-obsessed” schools and laptops and tablets in the classroom.
The public, though, isn’t as frightened as the headlines. In a 2025 NBC News poll, 53% of American adults said bringing AI into the classroom better prepares students for the future, while 47% said banning it does.
In many of my articles on FlyoverCountry.us, including “Technophobia,” I’ve written about the panic that greets nearly every new technology, from the printing press to the telephone, computers and now AI. It’s an old story. Nearly 2,400 years ago, in Plato’s Phaedrus, Socrates warned that the invention of writing would “create forgetfulness in the learners’ souls” and give students “not truth, but only the semblance of truth.” When ChatGPT arrived, New York City’s public schools banned it in January 2023, then lifted the ban that May, with the schools chancellor admitting the first reaction had been driven by “knee-jerk fear.” The fears aren’t always wrong, but they’re usually overblown, and once a new technology becomes part of everyday life, we find ways to make it work for us.
How I Use It
I’ve also been open about how I collaborate with AI. It amplifies my ability to research and write about things that interest me and, I hope, my readers. I come up with the ideas, the topics and the format, and I write out my thoughts in detail. After many years as a writer, performer, entertainer and content creator, I’ve gotten pretty good at communicating, but AI nearly always improves what I’ve worked on.
My son has expressed concerns about my use of AI. His criticism was constructive and offered with love and respect: he’d rather read what I write in my own words, and he said some of it sounded artificial and forced. He was right. My first experience with an AI writing tool was a trial of Grammarly on a few stories I posted on Medium. When I went back and reread them, I agreed with him, and I rewrote every one. Today I publish most of the content on my three websites with the help of Claude, an AI assistant, and over the past year it has learned my voice. When I hand it a draft, what comes back sounds more like me, not less, and often says what I think and feel more clearly and precisely than I did.
Dad, Can You Help Me?
Which isn’t all that different from the way I helped my own kids at home. When my daughter was 12, I showed her how to use Photoshop and other programs, and she used them in junior high to create graphics and message-board posts for American Juniors, the 2003 American Idol spinoff. Today she’s a very successful graphic artist with an advertising and website development company of her own.
My son worked side by side with me when he was young, building early websites about Mortal Kombat and other games he loved. All through high school I edited and advised him on reports and homework, and showed him how to research online, using Wikipedia and a variety of other sources. I never did his homework for him, but I was there to guide him. It was always a collaboration. Today he’s a talented website designer and developer with a reputation, clientele and income I could only dream about.
That’s the point of the two cartoons. In 1985, nobody called it cheating when Dad helped with a book report, as long as Dad didn’t write it. The line was never between help and no help. It was between helping a student think and doing the thinking for them. The critics are right that a student who lets a chatbot write the report learns nothing, but that was just as true of a kid in 1985 who copied the encyclopedia word for word. Even the Brookings report, for all its warnings, found that AI can help students with organization, grammar and revision, as long as the students still do the writing themselves. That’s exactly the rule I followed with my own kids.
Slop, Scams and the Way Forward
There will always be people looking to game the system. When the internet was new, multilevel marketers flocked to it by the hundreds, selling snake oil to people hoping to get rich. There are just as many con artists online today, including politicians and media personalities who chase followers, votes and ad revenue by promoting fear-mongering stories and flatly false information.
And plenty of others hope to cash in by typing a few words into an AI program, telling it to write a story on some simple topic, publishing whatever comes out and asking readers to “buy me a coffee.”
I post my own articles on Medium, and I often find interesting pieces there to reference on my websites. But open the daily listings and you’ll wade through a flood of listicles, the “10 Best This” and “10 Worst That,” that read as if someone typed “Write a story about the 10 best (something)” into a chatbot and hit publish. It isn’t just my impression. In 2024, Wired reported on two AI-detection companies that analyzed Medium posts. One estimated that about 40% of that year’s posts were likely AI-generated, up from 3.4% in 2018, and the other put the figure at more than 47%. Medium’s CEO disputed the numbers, but acknowledged that AI-written posts had grown roughly tenfold that year.
That’s AI slop, and it’s everywhere. The best way to stop it is to ignore it: don’t read it, don’t share it and never subscribe to it.
But AI is here to stay. Learn to use it to build on your own creative talents, to discover better ways of doing things, to find cures, advance science and help fix our country’s problems. The sooner we work together to manage, regulate and make full use of artificial intelligence, the better off we’ll all be.
Sources & Further Reading
- NPR: The risks of AI in schools outweigh the benefits, report says (Jan. 2026)
- District Administration: Teachers union urges schools to curb AI chatbots and screen time (May 2026)
- Michael R. Bloomberg: AI Won’t Give Kids the Education They Need (Oct. 2025)
- Fox News: Sanders says “science-fiction fear” of AI running the world “not quite so outrageous” (Dec. 2025)
- Soap Central: Hugh Grant campaigns against laptops and tablets in classrooms
- NBC News poll: Americans divided on AI’s role in school and everyday life (2025)
- NBC News: New York City public schools remove ChatGPT ban (May 2023)
- Plato, Phaedrus (Benjamin Jowett translation)
- CO/AI, summarizing Wired: Medium is being flooded with AI-generated content (Oct. 2024)