Editorial cartoon: a frazzled woman at a gas pump stares in horror at a $100.00 total while money flutters out of her open purse. Behind her, two billboards, one red and one blue, each show an angry politician under the same word, AFFORDABILITY!, pointing furiously at each other.
AI-generated illustration created for this piece.

Every two years, the two major U.S. parties pick a very few issues to campaign on, hoping to capitalize on whatever they believe is uppermost in voters’ minds. Here are the catchphrases each party leaned on over the past sixteen years:

YearRepublicansDemocrats
2010“Tea Party” · “Repeal Obamacare” · “Spending”“Recovery Summer” · “Jobs”
2012“Believe in America” · “We Built It” · “Job Creators”“Forward” · “The 47 Percent”
2014“Obamacare” · “Ebola” · “ISIS”“War on Women” · “Raise the Wage”
2016“Make America Great Again” · “Build the Wall” · “Drain the Swamp”“Stronger Together” · “I’m With Her”
2018“The Caravan” · “Jobs, Not Mobs”“Pre-existing Conditions” · “Blue Wave”
2020“Law and Order” · “Promises Kept”“Build Back Better” · “Trust Science”
2022“Inflation” · “Crime” · “Red Wave”“Roe” · “Democracy” · “MAGA Extremists”
2024“Drill, Baby, Drill” · “Seal the Border” · “No Tax on Tips”“We’re Not Going Back” · “Reproductive Freedom” · “Project 2025”
2026“Affordability!”“Affordability!”

Campaign slogans, rally chants and the labels each side leaned on most. Some were official slogans; others were simply the words voters heard over and over.

Notice 2026? For the first time in sixteen years, both columns say the same thing. The word itself isn’t brand new — Donald Trump promised to “make America affordable again” on the 2024 campaign trail — but this is the first time both parties have grabbed it at once.

Whenever my wife and I go shopping for groceries, stop at a fast food joint, dine at a nice restaurant, or just look at furniture or think about a new or used car, I can count on hearing a sigh of frustration and the same few words:

“Everything is SO expensive these days!”

And she’s right, of course — though my answer is always the same: “Prices ALWAYS go up over time. Nothing will ever change that.” That frustration is exactly why both the Democrats and the Republicans are campaigning so heavily on “affordability” this fall. Gasoline and diesel prices are painful right now, and this is neither the time nor the place to discuss the pros and cons of the conflict with Iran and the ongoing problems in the Middle East.

Nevertheless, I wondered how prices for everyday consumer goods in the United States have actually changed. Have they really gone up in a startling, unmanageable way? You might recall the uproar across the country in March of last year, when the national average price of a dozen eggs hit $6.23.

Today, a dozen eggs at one Minneapolis store will cost you $1.49, and another store had them on sale for 99 cents a dozen. Many factors go into setting prices, and perhaps eggs are just an outlier. So I dug into ten years of government price data for the things families buy most.

What Ten Years Did to Everyday Prices

ItemAug 2016Aug 2025Aug 202610 yearsPast year
Eggs (dozen)$1.46$3.59$2.27+56%−37%
Milk (gallon)$3.14$4.17$4.23+35%+1%
Butter (lb)*$4.09$4.83$4.02−2%−17%
Ground beef (lb)$3.66$6.32$6.92+89%+10%
Coffee (lb)$4.32$8.87$9.30+115%+5%
Bananas (lb)$0.56$0.67$0.65+16%−2%
Electricity (kWh)13.9¢19.0¢19.6¢+41%+3%
Rent———+51%+3%
Eating out———+51%+3%
Car insurance———+79%−5%
Internet service———+14%+3%
Cell phone service———−17%−2%
All prices+39%+3.4%
Average hourly pay$25.71$36.62$37.76+47%+3.1%

National averages from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. *The butter survey begins in 2018, so that row starts in August 2018. Rent, eating out, car insurance, internet and cell service are measured as price indexes rather than single prices. Gasoline is left out on purpose — more on that below.

+39%
overall prices, 2016–2026
+47%
average hourly pay, same ten years
−64%
eggs, from the March 2025 peak
2×
monthly payment on a new home since 2021

Prices overall went up 39% over the past ten years. But on average, paychecks went up even faster: 47%.

That doesn’t mean people are imagining things. In 2021 and 2022, prices jumped 14% in two years while pay rose only 10% — and prices don’t come back down once they go up. The average worker has only recently caught back up.

Rose faster than the 39% average

  • Rent: +51%
  • Eating out: +51%
  • Car insurance: +79%
  • Ground beef: +89%
  • Coffee: +115%

Actually cost less

  • Eggs: down 37% from a year ago, and 64% from the March 2025 peak
  • Butter: less than it cost in 2018
  • Car insurance: down 5% from a year ago, after back-to-back jumps of about 18% in 2023 and 2024
  • Cell phone service: down 17% over ten years (while you get far more data for the money)

What About Gas?

I left gasoline out of the chart on purpose — not to hide it, but because it swings too wildly to tell us anything about a ten-year trend. That’s the same reason the government’s own “core” inflation measure leaves out food and energy.

Gas Prices Are a Roller Coaster

  • 2008: The national record was $4.11 a gallon (AAA, July 17, 2008) — driven by record world oil prices.
  • 2022: A new all-time record of $5.01 (AAA, June 14, 2022) — Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on top of post-pandemic demand.
  • 2026: The national average was $4.20 in August — the Iran war.

Adjusted for inflation, the 2008 record would be about $6.25 today and the 2022 record about $5.65. Today’s $4.20 is painful, but it’s cheaper in real terms than either of those peaks.

The Real Squeeze: Buying a House

The biggest affordability problem isn’t in the grocery cart. It’s buying a house. The monthly payment on a typical new home has roughly doubled since 2021.

Housing in three numbers
Home priceMortgage rateMonthly payment*Hours of average pay
2016$303,800~3.45%$1,08542
Early 2021 (record-low rate)$355,0002.65%$1,14437
Now$410,700~7.4%$2,27560

Median price of a new home, buyer putting 20% down, 30-year fixed mortgage. *Principal and interest only; taxes and insurance are extra. Sources: U.S. Census Bureau/HUD, Freddie Mac, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

The home itself is only 35% more expensive than in 2016 — less than pay rose (47%). New-home prices have actually slipped about 7% from their 2022 peak. What more than doubled the payment is the interest rate. At today’s price but 2016’s rate, the payment would be about $1,470.

But interest rates aren’t set by a party platform. Markets and the Federal Reserve drive them, and the Fed is independent by design. The rest of the housing squeeze — a decade of too little home building, owners who won’t give up their 3% mortgages, and local zoning rules — is slow-moving and local. No candidate can fix it by next spring.

The Shiny Object

The cost of living is real. The promises are the cheap trick.

No president or member of Congress sets the price of eggs, coffee or rent. Eggs fell 64% from their peak because egg-laying flocks recovered from bird flu, not because anybody was elected. When either party says “elect us and things will be affordable again,” they’re selling something they can’t deliver.

What Is Seen, and What Is Not Seen

Seen: A single word on every yard sign, ad and debate stage — and the price tag you just paid at the store.

Not seen: Paychecks that outran prices over the decade, the things that got cheaper, and the forces — bird flu, world oil markets, interest rates — that no candidate controls.

“Affordability,” the slogan, is the shiny object — bright enough to hold your attention while the people waving it hope you won’t ask what they’ll actually do about it.

So ignore the accusations, the blame game, and the attempts by both Democrats and Republicans to gin up your anger and frustration. Don’t vote in November expecting relief based on false promises and misrepresentations. Get informed, and vote for candidates who talk about real, substantive issues and offer legitimate, workable solutions for our state and our nation.

When a candidate promises to make things affordable again, ask one question: exactly how?

Sources & Further Reading